China has NEVER said Sorry, EVER!


Christian Filipina Asian Ladies Dating 700x100 wide animated banner 1

600 comments

  1. Matebook 13 – Macbook air; Having had access to both products, I’ll agree that’s a clear rip off, but it comes down to price Vs. branding – Both companies would sell you out to the highest bidder/affiliation
    The “art”… yeah, everyone sees what they’re doing there.
    Military hardware is a different story IMO. Cloning a F-35 is not in China’s wheelhouse – They might be able to purchase some IP but some veins run deeper than their pockets. Can’t personally speak much on the UH-60, but I wouldn’t dismiss certain parallels ( That said I doubt – given past experience – that under finer scrutiny, the Harbin wouldn’t raise many eyebrows).

  2. Chinese parents never say sorry to their children. It’s a Confucian thing. They’re always right and use shame to keep the kids in line. Sound familiar?

  3. What a load of nonsense.
    The Chinese communist party has condemn and a criticized the great leap forward and the cultural revolution more than 30 years ago.
    This video full is an embarrassment.
    You should really learn about China and Chinese history before you talk about it.

  4. After the death of Mao which ended the “cultural revolution”, the communist Party’s appraisal of the dictator Mao was that what Mao accomplished is 70 per cent good 30 per cent bad, so the contribution overcame damage.
    In 1949, when CCP took control of China, Mao made a policy quota to kill 10% of the population for being from exploiting rich class, fortunately he didn’t fulfill his quota for killing 40 millions, he killed just one million of the rich,
    Then during 1958-1961 period of starvation which was caused by big leap policy, another 30 millions were starved to death,
    In 1966-1976 so called “Cultural Revolution” coup, Mao purged his rivals including the Chairman Liu Shaoqi and intellectuals of China, costing around 1-2 million lives, and a new generation without any education.
    Above is his damage.
    What is Mao’s contribution? He lead Communist Partisans in remote parts of China massacring the rich and landowners, having their lands and wealth distributed to local farmers which gained support of people and Soviet Union, at the end defeating the government army which retreated to Taiwan.
    Then CCP controlled and lead the farmers into various experiments of social reengineering and industrialization, until 1978 when they realized that its experiments were not working at all,
    That’s the contribution of Mao, I think his contribution was to the CCP than to the people, he made people die and stay miserable while making CCP the new owner of everything including owning the people.
    CCP had to reintroduce market economy, property rights at the end to solve the economic problem and poverty, which was caused by the government.
    Just look at the Khmer rouge, which wiped out 20-25% its own people in just three years, which was supported by Mao , but put on a hold by Communist Vietnam. The Vietnamese take over of Cambodia is just like AlQaida liberating people from ISIS.
    The evil Communist Party is being praised by Muslims in concentration camps,
    People like Danny Haiphong are praising CCP while he’s belittling US imperialism and capitalism, which is to disguise that he is being paid by CCP.

  5. BTW my dude.. he world need MORE straight talkers like you… (don’t let them shut you down with heir calling you a racist) just lay the truth brother….. we need to hear it!

  6. As a start and a good example for your audience, please take off your shoes *and apologize for your past behavior* when visiting your friend’s home, and make a video to prove it. At least show us that you take off your shoes for your wife and daughter at home! Further, if you could please show and prove that you have done something to improve the situation in your motherland, then I will be convinced that you truly believe what you preach.

  7. This is excellent. I lived in Taiwan for 33 years and I always said that Taiwan had more Chinese culture than China. It he is a very accurate statement. There is very little Chinese culture in China. In fact, many of the old buildings were torn down and the bricks and the materials were resold, and new Copy buildings were erected it is place. These new buildings with a spitting image of the old buildings he tore down. So they got paid to tear down the building, paid to sell the old materials, and paid to build the copy buildings

  8. 在你们批评中国之前,你们应该学一些中文,学一些汉字,然后去中国的内网看看,中国大陆的网民是怎么批评西方人的。像我是两边都有逛,于是发现了这个很有意思的事情。中西方相互指责对方的用词都几乎是相同的。

  9. People who suffer from wrong think must be purged before they infect the rest of society. To prevent a resurgence of the illness, the government must “vaccinate” its children via the education system. Oh…and don’t forget your mask.

  10. sadly there are some people in general that has a problem admitting fault. I’ve dealt with people at work of any race where you can kindly talk to them about something. Their immediate response is that its your fault because they feel you are saying they did something that is wrong. they will go into full defense mode and blast you. Then you realize you have to be a jerk back at them in order for them to realize they fucked up but they won’t admit it anyways. They will just move on like it never happened but will try their best to prevent future mistakes with you. It’s as if never admitting wrong or saying sorry will make it as if the incident never happened.

  11. It’s amazing that you and C-Milk can’t see the obvious. You went to China with your dangerously suicidal, ethnomasochistic, degenerate, and subversive liberal Western beliefs, which already ruined your native South Africa and are now ruining the rest of the West, and are absolutely outraged that the Chinese won’t follow suit and subject their nation to the same extremely destructive liberal ideology of anti-racism, anti-nationalism, anti-censorship, and anti-totalitarianism. And even though China’s neo-fascist system is clearly working as they rapidly develop and are projected to overtake America as the new leading global superpower sometime this century, you still can’t see that their mindset is clearly working and is superior to the liberal ideology that you were brainwashed with. You and C-Milk wanted the Chinese to act like Western White people by ruthlessly criticizing their own history, people, and civilization to death while simultaneously going out of their way to ensure that you felt completely welcome in their country. Instead, the Chinese nationalists basically asserted their dominance over you and told you to get the fuck out of their country. Hmmm. I wonder which nation, people, and civilization will come out on top by the end of this century: the self-hating liberal White Westerners, or the unapologetic and aggressive Chinese nationalists? It’s such a mystery…

  12. Hey sepentza you are educated more then Gwelio69, Jayoe nation, creepy Barrett, Nathan Poor, jerry pussy cat, and butterflies media. Hat off to you friend

  13. Why would I believe you on your facts? Maybee you are a propogandaist working for a secret government program. You need to say something to convince us!

  14. If you don`t admit that you do something wrong, you don`t do something wrong= Xi Jinping logic. The picture that hangs above the entry to the forbidden city says it all. If you openly glorify a monster like him, then there isn`t much more to talk about. That is equal to Germanys government hanging a picture from Hitler over the entrance of the Reichstag. No one would say “Ah yes, good idea”

  15. “What about Black Friday?” What about Black Friday? It got a little out of control in the US, but it was overhyped for marketing reasons, and has been less crazy in recent years. Have you ever seen a Canadian Black Friday? The customers politely line up outside the stores and wait for the doors to open.

  16. You have to understand, this is China you’re talking about. You get upset shows you still haven’t really understand China despite living there for more than a decade and even married a China woman. Sorry for being blunt, but I’ll say not in your lifetime will you see what you hope to see, not for at least another 2 centuries.

  17. At the very least xi could make an address to the world citing chinas willingness to help the world overcome covid, if not accepting responsibility for the current status quo…..if he needs a translator fair enough but the silence is deafening and merely gives the world community the impression this was deliberate….

  18. Mao was an uneducated fool. Too bad there were too many of the similar uneducated, aka stupid, fools at the time to know any better. There’s a saying “poverty is also a crime” which is very true because poverty makes people stupid and easily controlled and manipulated by those with hidden agendas.

  19. The 2 countries you criticized in this video are the most successful countries in human history so far, and that alone says a lot more than all of your and Laowai86’s videos combined. Both countries are fighting harder than anyone else to find a path and a future for mankind and for that, they get my respect no matter what. It is unfortunate they are rivals now and I hope they don’t become enemies, b/c our future relies largely on these giants.

  20. I’m an algerian my country lived through all kind of bad leaderships & invasions horrible crisis visited us yet glad that our moral compass is still the same still right same for the rest of the arab world all the corruption all the extremist violent idealogies didn’t find home in our society except for few individuals we know all this is wrong & we want to change our reality maybe for the next generations but never accept & defend the corrent situation

  21. Saving face is a result of collectivistic societies where the collective is more important than the individual.

    in an individualistic society (where the individual has a value of its own), face saving is a choice of the individual. Some individuals care about saving face. Some individuals don’t give a damn. Ignoring what other people think about you is one of the biggest life hacks.

  22. Mao was absolutely right about sparrows. Having watched many sparrows in mating rituals with inflexible gender roles and a clear cisgender binary patriarchy. if Sparrows aren’t outright transphobic capitalists, they are at the least insufficiently revolutionary and indifferent to the proletariat cause. They are also aggressive expansionists who would happily occupy the native lands of the noble Robin Redbreast. Down with Sparrows. They are just tiny vultures.

  23. In our history books, the chapter for “Tian anmen square massive massacre toward young students ” does not exist, most of young Chinese even don’t know about it, older teachers who witnessed about the whole events never talked about it, the chapter for “cultural revolution and big leap” do exist but the conclusion of the crazy mistake is because of “EVIL WESTERN INFLUENCE wants to destroy the newborn communist China ” , the whole education target is to brainwash young Chinese generation and indoctrinated the endless hatred mentality toward foreign countries such as USA and Japan , Our teachers constantly underlined that Mao do make small mistakes, but he is still a great leader that drag billions of Chinese out of darkness, he is the embodiment of the “GOD” , and we should ignore his small mistakes, this is how billions of brainless nationalists cultivated, because the real history was already wiped away from the history book or distorted and only the hatred mentality is imbedded into the Chinese ideology. The CCP perfectly knows how to manipulate the Chinese people, dictatorship itself doesn’t need any empathy and compassion, so the whole social environment is also full of brutality and indifference.

  24. Do not think they have the word sorry in their language.
    Yesterday Canada was told not to allow Hong Kongers
    a safe country to go to. The threat was that Candadians
    living in Hong Kong or China would not be safe if we did so.
    Hard to believe how aggressive they have become.

  25. “The bad actions are everywhere why don’t you criticize others, I only killing one person and lots of more people are being killed everywhere, people gonna die anyways”…. I know what they would be saying…

  26. Dearest Winston, thank you for all your hard work and everything you and Matthew do. But today I couldn’t get past the few moments into the history of the sparrow. I can’t handle that kind of pain. Thank you for trying to bring truth into the culture of the Chinese. I could only hope did the future Generations have learned to protect our environment. With love to you and your family, Shelley and Hugo

  27. I love this guy he tell the truth about communist it’s kind of similar to my country Laos, communist regimes is teaching the young generation wrong way about their history

  28. Seriously nobody cares it’s just racism get over it you live in the US stop it or go back to South Africa, I don’t need no more of this bullsh*t go home

  29. I’ve seen this grab culture on a cruise ship, the crew had to guard the food stations from the Chinese passengers as they descended upon them like locusts grabbing anything and everything, I’d never seen anything like it before. ✔

  30. China still hasn’t apologized for releasing a biological weapon, Covid-19. The reason….because if they did the Communist Party would get their own Nuremburg. The world needs to make a new closed door policy to China….nothing gets out.

  31. Feed it to em brother! When is enough gonna be enough?when there’s no fish,air,water etc?let’s go to war! Why did the aggressive nature of the un change for communist countrys?oh that’s right after Vietnam!

  32. This is very much speaking for their society as well, and I’ve spent a while in a this country I never felt welcomed. Chinese (generalized) do not apologize, are not very careful about words or actions, neither are they ashamed. Foreigners are a collective, the rest of the world besides the big nation, the only worthy above all others but with manners we spend our nights playing “middle age” as kids, burping slurping spitting and yelling. Quote Einstein:”Never argue with stupid people, they’ll drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience!”

  33. I worked in China for 8 years and admittance of a mistake, or apologies just do NOT exist. I think Trump now plays from the same playbook ….. blame anyone else.

  34. The toxic “face” culture basically discourages people from acknowledging their mistakes. Hence China lives in delusion where everyone else is at fault except for China.

  35. The justification for the grab hags is hilarious. Wouldn’t past starvation make you extra careful about not wasting food? Only according to Chinese logic would the response be to pile on food and let it rot. No wonder Einstein said those brainwashed, braindead zombies are obtuse and a menace to the future of mankind.

  36. The rotten behavior of the CCP has trickled down to the people, I have never encountered even a Chinese person who would apologize when they were wrong, it’s so typical China and it’s bad because when they donẗ realize they have done wrong then how can they correct themselves?
    Stop hiding behind the fake “must save face” excuse!

  37. They cannot apologize for anything because they would lose face. In China the only thing that matters is how you are perceived by others so showing any weakness will not be tolerated. Complete authority must be maintained. Let’s not let things like truth, justice, or common sense impede upon or decisions! These are childish ways of thinking. So afraid of the world they would burn everything down, themselves along with it.

  38. Great honesty and factual video, Winston. How about the genocide of having the one child policy? Now China don’t have enough brides for their countrymen.

  39. You Are Polish guy from South Africa, as first you came to Asia because some Comic Con or Something… You have Chinese wife and you few months ago talking about China only good things! So Winston What are kind of hypocrisy you present Here and Who Pay for it?!

  40. China’s cultural progress ended about 700 years ago. Going to China is like visiting a past. See an ancient tribal people that will lie, steal, cheat, do whatever they want with no remorse.

  41. China has a lot to answer for. How dare they kill innocent birbs that ate the bugs that ate their grain! How dare they throw plastic in the ocean and kill animals! How dare they poach wild animals for their body parts and call it “traditional medicine”! They allowed COVID to spread and punished whistleblowers for telling the truth! Mainland China has created a tragedy of the commons! Why doesn’t the UN step in and stop this shit?

    If I ever go to a culturally Chinese country, I’ll visit Taiwan instead of the mainland. That’s where the real stuff is. Mainland China only has 71 years of history and culture to work with no thanks to Mad Mao. Maybe I might put Hong Kong and Macau on my travel list, but that’s about it until and unless the mainland cleans up its act. Free Hong Kong, Tibet, and East Turkestan; overthrow Winnie the Pooh!

  42. Yeah, and where is PETA and SPCA in all this? Cowards, they are quick to go after you and use American laws to persecute you as an American. If they REALLY care about animals, PETA and SPCA go to China and MAKE them stop the cruelty to animals. These organizations should be the first to sound the trumpet against cruelty to animals in China. Not a peep from PETA and SPCA when it comes to China.

  43. Ofc its China fault but even so Trump had a responsibility to least take measures to stop the spread even if it costed the US money, knowning Trump would probably claim he will make China pay for it but Trump did not even do that, its not an excuse to take no measures against the spread.

  44. Seems like the ccp tries to do a lot of “quick fixes” not really thinking about the solution in the long run. Idk I could be wrong. 🤷🏻‍♂️
    China.. land of copy-cats.

  45. What do you expect the Chinese government to say we’ve committed atrocities and we want to apologize for them and do better that’s not how it works with the communist government. When I was there they would show the first 20 minutes of their local news of all the good things that happens in China and then the last 10 minutes would be all the bad things that are happening in the US and around the world and that’s always gonna be the case the Chinese don’t change and why would you expect them to apologize for anything God give me a break

  46. The other thing I learned while living there the Chinese have freedom but it’s controlled freedom you’re not allowed to protest or demonstrate or say anything bad about the government or else you’ll be thrown in jail and this goes for foreigners that are living there you can’t criticize the government I just think it’s beyond naïve to think the Chinese war apologize for past governmental atrocities like the way Mao starved millions and millions of his own citizens and what they’re doing today it’ll never happen

  47. Covid has never been isolated…The tests woefully inadequate….How many people (healthy people) do you or anybody know who has died of “covid” ??

  48. The Chinese see themselves as the perpetual victim. “Why should we apologize to anyone? It’s the world who must apologize to US, and keep apologizing, FOREVER!”

  49. The west has committed many atrocities and really continues to do it but in a much more stealthy way. This does not forgive China( CCP) it’s just a statement of fact

  50. Winston, I to I’am not lazy, I know their HISTORY! Everyone here have to find out for themselves to, do their homework! Once you find out who, where, why, then all history, all deception goes out the window! Everyone here take note.

  51. In spite of in the past I used to think an atheist society with no spiritual values was no different of any other, today I do think spiritual principles indeed make the people more compassionate and altruistic. In China the widespread atheism makes compassion no more than an option. The majority of the population don’t believe in the afterlife nor in any sort of spirituality. The concept of a loving God doesn’t exist nor any spiritual accountability. The people in China are focused solely in materialism and they see no reason to be good. That’s why life in China has way less importance than any other society in the world.

  52. They certainly apologize that other countries make mistakes
    And saying modern China has 5,000 years of culture is like saying “China invented paper, therefore nobody but us can use it.” It’s a retarded argument that makes no sense

  53. Hello! I just came for the Wooooooomao’s.

    If some one would kindly direct me to them it would be greatly appreciated. Thanking you in advance…

  54. Winston it’s worth mentioning that the Chinese population was under subjugation for 200 years prior to Mao…they were conquered by the Dutch and English as well as 19th century US ..
    And now they have a population 3 times the size of any country….soooo safety in numbers…..eventually polluting and consuming all food sources on the planet…their only competition being India (the second largest economy)…meanwhile the poor American red pills 💊 stay numb on red pills 💊 and gloat about being a first world nation.

  55. I think it is a good point about people acting selfish & uncivilized during black friday sales. That is also wrong & needs to be improved.. By mentioning other people acting badly you are showing a lot of people need to do work to get better & that their is a global problem, not reducing your own countries accountability.

  56. China will get away with its past crimes, its current crimes and its racism. In no small part thanks to the people you are praising for teaching our children about our crimes, Winston. Also, what is with this obsession with saying sorry for things that happened in the past? As long as the current victims and purpetrators are still alive, yes, then it needs to happen. But for things like slavery or colonialism, the people and the victims no longer alive, that’s not healthy either. Take Germany, still bending over backwards to apologize for WW2 when the current generations bear no guilt in what happened. The sins of the father do and should not befall onto the sons. Forcing people to apologize for things you had no part in is a campaign to make you responsible for the sins of the father. Because then They own you.

  57. One lesson under taught is how many American companies thought there wouldn’t be issue with doing business with the Nazi’s early on. Sure enough the NBA and numerous other’s like Mark Cuban are sucking up to a fascist, genocidal, dictatorship but this time it’s commies so it’s cool.

  58. That rude behavior comes from the farmers. Not necessarily all Chinese. They do the same in Vietnam. It’s push and shove, cut the line. The thing is foreigners don’t really live and deal with the farm people since foreigners don’t speak Viet and the rural people don’t speak English. EVEN if you tell these people they are being rude. They don’t listen. Because that’s the norm.

  59. China washes their crimes through the CCP washing machine, no wonder the dirt wont wash out. God will call them to answer for their public sin. We all answer to God even the nonbelievers.

  60. You know what’s funny is I had a nationalist compare the camps in Xinjiang to our community service centers in the US. You read it right here people. A nationalist compares Cultural genocide to *community service.*

  61. I think Mao Zedong was a mentally retarded person when he ordered to kill all the sparrows in China and blame poor small birds for starvation…smh, not to mantion about him killing thousands of Chinese people who were against communist ideology

  62. Wow!…Just look at what you’ve become. So sad. I used to enjoy your videos from when you were living in China. Now you’re sounding like a paid US Government operative. I hope I’m wrong…

  63. Winston, it’s frightening. The China of tomorrow are super scary. But US, Europe and all of our allies. I honestly don’t think they stand a chance. Did you see the whole Galapagos fishing incident? I’m literally about to sign up. Crazy to think they were our allies 50 years ago. Europe, combined, could wipe them off planet earth.

  64. Ofcourse all left wing regimes rely on controlling the past and lying- zero interest in learning only in so raining communist party power. That’s why they’re scum irrespective of what dim youtubers over there are Impressed with..

  65. Honestly, I stay at home on Black Friday, I find it to be disgusting, if I want a new TV that bad, I will pay the extra to simply avoid the crowds. Most Black Friday sales really aren’t that great anyway, they bring in stuff just for those sales that isn’t as good as the regular stuff. All that said, the behavior of many of those people is absolutely juvenile.

  66. Because, as we all learned in the 60’s movie “Love Story,” being in love means never having to say you’re sorry, right? Therefore, China is pure LUV!!

  67. Sorry Winston, but “genocide of Native Americans” is a gross myth that never actually happened. Sure, Native Americans and Europeans skirmished and fought selective battles for hundreds of years, and naturally, the more technologically advanced group (Europeans) came out on top in most instances, but “genocide” never actually happened anywhere on the continent. Pretty important distinction, I think.

  68. China never apologizes for putting tens of millions of its own people into camps. We need to condemn china and put as heavy sanctions as what Iran has gotten and hoped it will change.

  69. In China saying sorry comes with responsibility of reparations, and Chinese people never want to pay back even if they’re in the wrong. In fact, they’re the loudest when they demand apologies (ask Japan)

  70. America never apologized or acknowledged for 2 millions people it killed and displacing 30million more in the Middle East, it’s now starving Venezuelan netizens, it’s still blockading Cuba, it’s creating gangs in Central America to destabilize the region. Still has the audacity to lecture us about human rights issues. Old white men are afraid of Chinese dominance for being the first non Christian, none white country to become super power, to even surpass the USA.

  71. Communist and socialist governments can never admit failure, ever. They can’t. You can’t have flaws when your system is supposed to bring utopia. Only a perfect system can bring about a perfect society. That is the logic of communism. They can never admit they are wrong, because if they are wrong then someone else is right and communism is all or nothing.

  72. Can you blame China though? They know Capitalism’s deep seated desires, GREED. Sow the greed with Chinese money, watch capitalists sell out Democracy in favor of profits because for corporations, money is the end game which in turn degrades democracy further when the kowtowing ends with censorship, cancel culture, etc. In the end, China will and may win the long game as they snake their way into your everyday life and control what you say about them or suffer repercussions just like how they’ve done with the the liberals and their corporations. $$$$ ya’ll.

  73. Not only hasn’t the USSA apologized for discriminating Black, Brown and Red citizens, but the discrimination goes on. While our minorites pay taxes to support our vaunted national parks and forests just like our privileged Whites, you will hardly see a minority face in any of them. The answer is not to bus them all to Yellowstone and Yosemite, but to stop charging them for acquisition and maintenance of those natural country clubs loved by the privileged Whites. All public lands should be privatized like Disney World, Busch Gardens and Universal Studios so that Whites pay fees for their privileges.

  74. Took America nearly a century to abolish slavery, another 100 years to abolish segregation, and another 50 years until 2008 when Congress officially apologized for slavery. The cultural revolution was around 1970, and in 1981 Chinese government passed resolution totally invalidated the cultural revolution. What a joke the U.S. is. Western civilization has yet to apologize for all the atrocities colonization has caused, by the facts that Americans, Canadians, and Australians are still living on lands stolen from indigenous people. If you’re really sorry about it, go back to Europe. Otherwise, you’re nothing but a phony.

  75. Russia doesn’t apologize for anything either. Heck, even Iran apologized the downing of the Ukrainian Air 752 in January 2020, but Russia and China never apologize for anything!

  76. The big problem of China is its regime, a criminal one, the CCP. Communism has killed more inocent people in history than Nazism,Fascism and the Islamic terrorism combined. The China as It is today is a monster that we Western Capitalists created, China is our Frankstein. The question now is how to kill this monster without affecting us all.

  77. 3:35 I dont wanna be that guy but those snips of “copied technology” are very excessive claims. To even compare the US F-35 which is a stealth aircraft to a joke non-stealth aircraft like China’s J-31. That plane is generations behind the F-35, and it isn’t even stealth! and most labtops look very very similar, that is also a bad comparison. Should have shown the Chinese Eiffel tower that was copied. Keeping in mind that the Eiffel tower actually is copyrighted. Or focus on Nortel’s products being copied by ZTE including the English instruction manual spelling errors.

  78. When I was in public middle school in Texas US, our history teacher would show us gruesome videos of cowboys gunning down native Americans & even killing babies, as well as other atrocities. There was no hiding it. The US owns up to their mistakes while China glorifies them.

  79. I don’t know why any Asians listen to or put up with their so called governments. The Asian people of this World have been absolutely massacred by the millions by their so called governments.

  80. Unfortunately there will be plenty more of this bad behavior to come. When you have the world’s most populous country, which has been mostly de-coupled from the western world but now opened up and mostly integrated (for say the last 30yrs), being run by an authoritarian, expansionist dictatorship carrying on un-abated, I feel this will only become more apparent. I think we need to isolate the dictatorship and band together as western alliance of nations to call out the CCP for who and what they are. The world stood by a let the nazi’s rise to dominance unchecked until it was too late. It feels like we are letting the same thing happen again, but this time with far ire consequences. I don’t think we in the west would ever be able to reconcile with the actions and ideologies of the CCP let alone any dictatorship. No lets all call them out. Winston your contribution to enhancing public awareness of the CCP is outstanding. It is also clear, honest and balanced, and I have to say your doing an incredible job and hope it continues.

  81. I read a lot of chinese novels @ wuxiaworld and i can relate to this. Apologizing for them is like a slap on the face and they would do anything to eliminate the threat or blame it to another person just to save their “face” is what always read on the novels lol.

  82. I teach English online to Chinese students (adults). I have a regular student who’s intelligent, fluent and a lovely well mannered woman. Briefly brought up the famine during Maos great leap ‘forward’. Laziness from China’s farmers was the subsequent reason for the mass starvation from her angle and not through Zedongs madness. Again, an intelligent woman and well mannered, but the delusions and saving face is frustrating and quite scary

  83. Hermès Conrad: “Professor, Sprinkle us with wisdom from your mighty brain. How scared should we be?”

    Professor Hubert J. Farnsworth: “ somewhere between not at all, and entirely.“

    Dr. John Zoidberg: “I call entirely! Aahhhhh!”

    Futurama movie called “The Beast with a Billion Backs

  84. America and Europe is not perfect either but at least they will probably admit there are problems and issues, sometimes they will apologize, but china will never admit nor apologize!

  85. What China? I deleted it from all my maps at home. China doesn’t exist as far as I’m concern. Taiwan is the only true center of Chinese culture and civilization.

  86. Winston, I agree with you wholeheartedly.
    You are understand Chinese culture more than most mainland Chinese.
    I think it’s because of your world views.
    Cheers.

  87. They learned from soviet union’s collapse. Pope visits Poland sparks the revolution? Then monitor and control all type of religious activities. Planned economy don’t works? Then use market economy to import technology but keep the dominance of national companies. Students and intellectuals want to start a revolution? Implement strongest censorship technology on the Earth and make dissidents disappeared. Too big and too guilty to apologize. To keep the power that will inevitably slip away, they will do everything and drag anything they can down with them.

  88. Do NOT vote Biden – Hunter Biden built his network in China unfortunately with the help of a sketchy Taiwanese man (though majority of Taiwanese support democracy)

  89. At the time of my viewing this video… 2.8k thumbs up from regular YouTube viewers. 82 thumbs down from Chinese YouTube bots. Keep on doing what you do Winston. We appreciate you, friend!

  90. I just started to listen to an audio version of “Why Nations Fail”, and China… it doesn’t look good, capitalism and _sort of_ free market has not, do not and will not prevent any country from failing if there are no other ingredients necessary for futher advancements in economics and technology, and development of a stable society.

  91. as much as I agree about the responsability about covid… can they afford to admit to anything?
    that would give credence to all other countries who want to sue them… so of course they will not admit to anything…

  92. The Yulin dog meat festival, where mainland Chinese people TORTURE defenseless dogs to death (I.e. boiling them alive) tells so much about the Chinese people of today. This is going on NOW and the Chinese mainland people refuse to stop it!
    Thank you, Winston, this episode is a keeper! I’ve been told over and over that it’s the CCP that is bad…the Chinese people are “innocent!” WRONG! There is much wrong with your 70-year-old “culture” that you could be doing so much about! I hereby call you out and challenge you to make the entire world a safer and better place by refusing to accept the Chinese communist party as your government! Disrespect for Chinese as a people is growing because they stand by like cowards and refuse to take on the much needed dirty work of reforming their OWN government!

  93. I’m 1 minute into the video. For years you’ve praised China now it’s all bad. Like you I’m married to a Chinese girl and have a baby too. I don’t like all this negatively. Sorry but I won’t watch anymore. I wish you well but bye bye. 😧

  94. I think this is the best video about china ive ever seen. It need to be seen by everyone this is sooo much truth. Bless you brother. May you stay safe

  95. Saving face should not be coddled!
    Natural, consequential feelings of shame improve character through humility; the willingness to learn. Feeling the painful effects of shame, learning to be shame adversive, taking right action in the first place improves the individual character, and by extension, a Nation.
    Author Scott Peck defines “evil” as the unwillingness to support one’s own, or deprive another’s personal growth. Growth.
    There is a purpose for the feeling of shame!
    Even my CAT is capable of feeling it and self-correcting his own behavior!
    A DOG will show shame, and likely live to feel it again! 😆
    If this is an Asian thing, you ‘face-savers’ are irredeemable!
    Not worthy to be called “Human”.
    Worse than my cat.

  96. How do you say it is no problem, we just need to do our thing well, after all, now you have the right to speak, and at the same time against China in foreign countries also has a big market,It will attract many people who have never come to China to watch, which is also a way to make money.😂😂😂

  97. Serpentza i don’t know why you so upset with China ? Lets go back 300 years ago, no humanity was civil back then, China is doing it prolly next 2,3 generations, but their doing it their own way. I like the fact China doesn’t support handicapped and fat people like the west does. China is copying but soon they gonna start their own brand, it’s not like China is not capable. China will the worlds super power in next few years when their technology and building technologies go unmatched !

  98. Yea, as an American, I admit that we sometimes have Black Friday insanity. But what the ‘what aboutists’ ignore is that we then arrest and prosecute the culprits.

  99. I had to watch this twice.
    You’ve outdone yourself again, Winston.
    POWERFUL delivery.

    On a mundane note, you look handsome with hair.
    I really hope you’re recovery is complete.
    Kisses to Baby and Sasha!

  100. tRump is responsible for the deaths in the States. He will also be responsible for the deaths in the States until he is out of office. There is no way around that.

  101. Winston, I’ve followed you & cmilk in your early years in China and enjoyed your fair and balance views. I hope I’m wrong, but it seems, you’re the one who should apologize. China gave you opportunities, jobs, business and a wife, when you were at a dead end in So. Africa. Now you’re cashing in on the Anti-China movement. Politics aside, if you can’t show a little gratitude, then at least don’t add fuel to the fire. Fanning the flames of hatred will only result in bad karma. Don’t you want a peaceful world for your children? You may not believe this, but there are things more important than money.

  102. Why 1.4 billion Chinese support such an ashamed evil disgusting regime, CCP ???
    Do they really believe their government is doing good for China and Chinese citizen ???

  103. China hate thread on 4chan, hundreds of videos of chinese people torturing dogs and other animals to death truly abhorrent behaviour.
    one is a chinese man with a cigarette in one hand and a blow torch in the other, burning a dog to death hanging by its neck.

  104. Have said it before “Chinese are ethnocentric”, when they band together and collectively acknowledge their common attitude, they see it as nationalism!!!

  105. “Cultural Devolution” aka “Cultural Revolution” (1966,)

    Apt political observation

    Mao’s disastrous attempt to save face from the past disaster from the 1957 “Great Leap Backward” aka “Great Leap Forward”

    During the 1966 Cultural Revolution can you imagine a child or grandchild you reared and loved as a baby turning against you by informing Mao’s CCP of your “counterrevoltionary” speeches and activities?

    Some parents, grandparents, uncles, aunts, neighbors, etc were harassed, beaten, even murdered by CCP nationalists

    Terrible times indeed

  106. Interestingly enough, “Was it not the Kuomintang, the nationalists, who largely engaged the Japanese? After all, the Communists, who eventually defeated the Kuomintang in 1949, were in disarray in 1937.

    Didn’t Mao Zedong tell Japanese Prime Minister Kakuei Tanaka in Beijing in 1972, when diplomatic relations were restored between China and Japan, that if it hadn’t been for the Japanese, the Communists would never have taken power as the invasion gave them time to regroup under an umbrella of resistance to Japan?”

  107. I feel so sorry for those birds😭 The brainwashed ppl were extremely ignorant. The party is evil all the time and it is still threatening the lives of those who have known its dark history.

  108. Western media never say sorry for demonize China. China is is strong and prosperous today. If the Chinese government is so bad, how can China be so properous6 and safe today?

  109. I hope the CCP collapses soon and all Chinese people experience real freedoms of those like in Hong Kong (before they just took over) and like taiwan..mainland chinese need to go to the real china of Taiwan where the KMT resides..they were the ones who defended china from the Japanese. And while tired from the long fight Mao came and took advantage of the situation and pushed them to taiwan. Taiwan is the republic of china!!!

  110. For ALL those things you said Americans are taught in school are “bad”, there are MILLIONS of people who think they’re good, and argue that they’re good, and teach their children that they’re good.

    The president of the USA will not even say those things are bad. In front of the whole nation.

    America is a crazy place with a rough history that never learns it’s lessons.

    Half the people I know think Covid is a hoax for chrissakes. This response was a joke. And the government just packed up and went home after passing one bill that bailed out corporations.

    In 10 years, when the allure of America wears off of you, you’re gonna realize just how foolish you were for shilling like a good little puppet for us.

    Yeah yeah China is SO terrible so omg it’s so bad and awful and it’s just the WORST OMGGG SO BAD THAT PLACE and were so GOOD!! AMERICA YES GOD BLESS THE FREE WINSTON!! Plus everything America says is true and good and holy too right??? And everything China is satan bad evil demon yes!!!

    You are a joke of a human what an absolute pathetic clown.

  111. I honestly thought you were smarter than this… such a bland, uneducated video. “Bad” is such a vast and subjective word, it should never be used so many times in such a little span. Also being abused as a child, mental problems etc. ARE an excuse for “bad” actions like killing. You are just too small minded to even understand it.

  112. I have been to china twice. Total duration of stay 2 years. China’s growth story is due to fast and efficient administration of CPC. Comparing a huge country like china to taiwan is stupidity. Chinese and taiwanese marry and have family relations, both people are the same. Agreed that UK and USA have grf

  113. I agree with almost everything you said, although there are still some people out there that say that colonization was good and there was nothing wrong done to native Americans.

  114. I was a toy inventor and was very successful until I was alerted there are bootleg copies of the toys I INVENTED being made IN CHINA! I cannot sue as it is an impossible lawsuit so now the only recourse is to alert Customs and Border Control of my stolen products on the black market. Invent ANYTHING and it is guaranteed to be made into a bootleg version for a cheaper price by some sleazy ‘Me Too” lowlife. Have tons of inventions that will never be made public because of the constant theft of one’s creativity. *Keep ALL INVENTIONS to yourself! Others will exploit/profit from your creativity and hard work.*

  115. Winston, you know what is missing in the 5,000+ years of history of China? A consistent focus on the development of science and mathematics – which is highlighted by the lack of great scholars in these fields of studies. The concept of objectivity is required for such success in science and mathematics. As such much of the politics (and everything else) never really matured to a level where objective testing of actual policy can exist in a consistent manner, for example. They will never understand when you call something bad or the need to apologize so you can move on concepts as these are concepts that will require different perspectives and objectivity. It is however the right thing to do to call them out!

  116. “There has been no BAD actions in CCP history. All bad things happened either because of bad people, bad mother nature or bad foreign countries. What CCP can say sorry about? Your statement is a illogical question, full of bias, aim to attack and hurt 1.4 billion Chinese people’s heart. You have NO rights to speak about China.” A very likely response from CCP.

  117. To be fair most of the Native Americans died off do to European diseases that they were not immune to. But there were still some screwed up stuff that happened when America conquered the west such as forced relocation and the constant breaking of treaties made.

  118. My wife is Chinese and used to be one of the people who would see what you talked about and ignore it, try to pretend that its not true. But after watching your videos with her she’s beginning to acknowledge things. Keep it up Serpent Zed A

  119. First published in German, it has been republished in that language in at least twelve different editions in Germany, England, and America.

    Noticed it says published not written.

    because the political situation has been entirely changed, and the progress of history has swept from off the earth the greater portion of the political parties there enumerated.

    This notes there have been many forms of government before Democratic

    also that the remarks on the relation of the Communists to the various opposition parties

    Meaning other communist organizations have been established throughout history.

    A subsequent edition may perhaps appear with an introduction bridging the gap from 1847 to the present day; but this reprint was too unexpected to leave us time for that.

    Meaning each edition is a new translation. Why would new editions need to be needed?

    The cheap prices of its commodities are the heavy artillery with which it batters down all Chinese walls. It doesn’t talk about any other countries walls or boarders does it. Because as mentioned before the progress of history has swept from off the earth the greater portion of the political parties.

    Germany was the starting point to try and blame “white” and race as the root of the problems. Go read 48 laws of power. Division makes it subsequently easier to conquor.

  120. here is something, while watching your video a news story flashed on my phone it states the Chinese fleet the worlds largest accused of spearheading decline in once abundant squid stocks west cost of Africa , 15 Foregin ships for illegal fishing all but one was from China in 2019 for starters this reporter was on government boats reporting this , they have 200,000 to 800,000 around the world there not going to be happy until there the whole world is starving and then blame the west

  121. Really, the corona virus is not new. There is “no” new corona virus, the idiot people just believe what they are told. The corona virus that is killing old people has been killing them year after year along with the seasonal flu. Funny how there are virtually no flu deaths this year. If you put a spotlight on something doesn’t mean it is different

  122. Japan does the same: no apology for the war or the ‘coprosperity sphere’, no proper education about the causes that lead to the atomic bombs. The end result is that Japanese think they are the VICTIMS of ‘ano senso’ (literally ‘that war’) and that’s it’s their moral duty to teach the world about peace (imagine the nerve).

  123. Tbh. CHina couldn’t possibly have stopped the spread of COVID-19. And if they did, the media outside china would have had a story of “oh, China opresses its citizens yet again, how can you, China. Now the weather”. When it emerged how bad the virus is, it had already started spreading around the world. In this one case, there is literally nothing China could have done.

  124. How about the Terrorist States of America apologizing for Vietnam, Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya, Syria, Ukraine, Yougoslavia, Iran, Venezuela, Bolivia, Brazil and the other
    countries illegally sanctioned, bombed or invaded ? How about the Terrorist States of America apologizing for the countless war crimes and crimes against humanity committed ? The Terrorist States of America is the single greatest threat to world peace.

  125. when the ccp cult members thank ccp for murdering the students at Tiananmen square to adcance China, ccp have successfully brainwash chinese people to justify their evil communist government

  126. Just from a personal observation, my Chinese wife has never said sorry when she was wrong. I believe that it has do do with, “not losing face”. I believe that Chinese society is this way.

  127. China CCP used up up all the goodwill Around The World by harassing everyone and anyone and stealing fish out childish a country that steals fish that proves their only a third world country

  128. A lot of people want China to be ‘punished’ by banning imports etc from China, the problem is that the CCP has bought a lot of loyalty from poorer nations through the BRI and supporting dictators. So, the reality is that those nations have a vote in the UN (a useless, puppet of the CCP) and therefore China will NEVER be held accountable for anything. Just look at the fact they were elected to the UN Human Rights Council now.

    So, what’s the road ahead, how do we solve the CCP problem? I realistically think that the change has to come from within. The Chinese people are the biggest losers here, but they are so indoctrinated that they can’t see any fault with the CCP. I have some good Chinese friends, I lived there for more than 2 years and was treated by the people like a celebrity, but the CCP treated me like a piece of rubbish but they, the Chinese middle and upper class don’t see the need for change. You see, if you don’t rock the boat, don’t have any morals about the evilness of the CCP, their genocide, organ harvesting etc, then life is very convenient in China. Good transport system, food is available (though lately not so much), ease of paying (Alipay and WeChat Pay) etc etc, they just don’t see the need for change.

    So as much as we want change in China, the average Chinese person doesn’t give a flying fig and till they see it, it is not going to happen.

    What the world must do is defend Taiwan with all their might, because if Taiwan goes, next target in their sights is the Philippines and once they have those two nations, they control the South China Sea and well that is a disaster for the world.

    My appeal to the West is, speak to your government representatives, whatever country you are in and get them to recognise and support the wonderful democracy and true Chinese people of Taiwan.

    Taiwan is a tiny David waving his finger at a mighty Goliath but the West, through its lack of support haven’t given David his slingshot and pebbles yet. Come on the rest of the world, do the right thing.

    I am not talking about going to war with China unprovoked, I am talking about defense pacts with Taiwan. Xi is a bully but a coward, if he knows that Taiwan is backed by countries like the US, India, Australia, Japan, Korea etc, he will NEVER dare attack Taiwan, because he knows he will be wiped off the face of the earth before he can say dumpling.

  129. Another powerful video with justified critiques of China. However, most people who haven’t lived in China are not aware of this stuff at all. Even some Westerners who haven’t lived in China defend it.

  130. Maybe I need to look up my world history but has any country other than Germany and Japan ever apologized for anything really? While not saying China hasn’t done horrendous things, an admission of fault for any countries leaders is seen as a massive sign of weakness and an open opportunity for other nations to politically attack them.

  131. During the Cultural revolution all the trees were cut down right outside Beijing because they were planted by the wrong people. As a result the city had dirt and dust blowing constantly in the air.

  132. Once again you sounds very bitter and angry. Why ?? Of course many mistakes made by ccp when the country came out of civil war and chaos. The system is evolving all the time from bad to good. On the other hand democracy is not evolving, example the US system is stuck with corruption where money talks, every 4 years election is getting worse and worse … thumbs down for wanting to create world conflicts.

  133. The last time someone told me Communism is Chinese culture I told them that the idea communism was came from a German called Karl Marx. The look on that person’s face was priceless!
    I think only way we can improve the world is to open the internet, media and telecommunications so people can learn. The Great Firewall of China is probably the biggest obstacle for change. The CCP twists everything into a weapon so they can stay in power.

  134. Apologizing and “owning” the Chinese coronavirus Pandemic would go a long way to help mend the hatred the world feels towards China! ..1,108,605 world 🌎 deaths to date (Oct. 16th ). We will never forget the lies and lack of transparency from China that got us here!

  135. 𝘛𝘩𝘦 𝘊𝘊𝘗 𝘪𝘴𝘯𝘵 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘰𝘯𝘦𝘴 𝘦𝘢𝘵𝘪𝘯𝘨 𝘣𝘢𝘵𝘴, 𝘵𝘰𝘳𝘵𝘶𝘳𝘪𝘯𝘨 𝘤𝘢𝘵𝘴 𝘢𝘯𝘥 𝘥𝘰𝘨𝘴 𝘵𝘰 𝘥𝘦𝘢𝘵𝘩 𝘧𝘰𝘳 𝘧𝘶𝘯, 𝘳𝘶𝘯𝘯𝘪𝘯𝘨 𝘰𝘷𝘦𝘳 𝘬𝘪𝘥𝘴 𝘪𝘯 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘴𝘵𝘳𝘦𝘦𝘵 𝘢𝘯𝘥 𝘭𝘦𝘢𝘷𝘪𝘯𝘨 𝘵𝘩𝘦𝘮 𝘵𝘰 𝘥𝘪𝘦 𝘣𝘦𝘤𝘢𝘶𝘴𝘦 𝘪𝘵𝘴 𝘯𝘰𝘵 𝘵𝘩𝘦𝘪𝘳 𝘤𝘩𝘪𝘭𝘥, 𝘨𝘰𝘪𝘯𝘨 𝘵𝘰 𝘰𝘵𝘩𝘦𝘳 𝘤𝘰𝘶𝘯𝘵𝘳𝘪𝘦𝘴 𝘵𝘰 𝘴𝘵𝘦𝘢𝘭 𝘵𝘩𝘦𝘪𝘳 𝘳𝘦𝘴𝘰𝘶𝘳𝘤𝘦𝘴 𝘵𝘰 𝘴𝘦𝘯𝘥 𝘣𝘢𝘤𝘬 𝘵𝘰 Ƈ𝘩𝘪ŋƙ𝘭𝘢𝘯𝘥, 𝘶𝘴𝘪𝘯𝘨 𝘨𝘶𝘵𝘵𝘦𝘳 𝘰𝘪𝘭 𝘧𝘰𝘳 𝘤𝘰𝘰𝘬𝘪𝘯𝘨, 𝘩𝘢𝘤𝘬𝘪𝘯𝘨 𝘴𝘦𝘳𝘷𝘦𝘳𝘴 𝘧𝘳𝘰𝘮 𝘷𝘪𝘥𝘦𝘰 𝘨𝘢𝘮𝘦𝘴 𝘵𝘰 𝘤𝘰𝘳𝘱𝘰𝘳𝘢𝘵𝘪𝘰𝘯𝘴 𝘵𝘰 𝘨𝘰𝘷𝘦𝘳𝘯𝘮𝘦𝘯𝘵𝘴, 𝘤𝘰𝘮𝘮𝘪𝘵𝘪𝘯𝘨 𝘤𝘰𝘳𝘱𝘰𝘳𝘢𝘵𝘦 𝘦𝘴𝘱𝘪𝘰𝘯𝘢𝘨𝘦, 𝘮𝘢𝘬𝘪𝘯𝘨 𝘭𝘪𝘵𝘦𝘳𝘢𝘭 𝘣𝘰𝘰𝘵𝘭𝘦𝘨 𝘱𝘳𝘰𝘥𝘶𝘤𝘵𝘴… 𝘐 𝘤𝘰𝘶𝘭𝘥 𝘨𝘰 𝘰𝘯 𝘢𝘯𝘥 𝘰𝘯. Ƈ𝘩𝘪ŋƙ𝘴 𝘢𝘳𝘦 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘴𝘤𝘶𝘮 𝘰𝘧 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘦𝘢𝘳𝘵𝘩.

  136. 𝘊𝘩𝘪 𝘯𝘬𝘴 𝘵𝘩𝘪𝘯𝘬 𝘵𝘰𝘳𝘵𝘶𝘳𝘪𝘯𝘨 𝘢𝘯𝘪𝘮𝘢𝘭𝘴 𝘢𝘯𝘥 𝘬𝘪𝘭𝘭𝘪𝘯𝘨 𝘳𝘢𝘳𝘦 𝘰𝘯𝘦𝘴 𝘮𝘢𝘬𝘦𝘴 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘧𝘰𝘰𝘥 𝘵𝘢𝘴𝘵𝘦 𝘣𝘦𝘵𝘵𝘦𝘳 𝘢𝘯𝘥 𝘩𝘢𝘴 𝘩𝘦𝘢𝘭𝘪𝘯𝘨 𝘱𝘳𝘰𝘱𝘦𝘳𝘵𝘪𝘦𝘴, 𝘤𝘰𝘮𝘱𝘭𝘦𝘵𝘦𝘭𝘺 𝘳𝘦𝘵𝘢𝘳𝘥𝘦𝘥.

  137. A sign that the CCP are uncivil shows in their brutal theft of Chinese Citizens lands, savings, and property without fair, or even in some cases, compensation… Capitalism and the Laws doesn’t allow that kind of forceful theft of property and land…

  138. The CCP deserves a plague of locusts.
    Actually, if there were a plague which took the lives of every first born, there’d be hardly anybody left in China.

  139. @serpentza I been getting emails from seller from alibaba to forward it back to them I find out that sellers are all from China do you have any any idea about this????

  140. 1. Vatican has still not apologize for Goa Inquisition.
    And Britain dont teach its newer generation about the genocides, its colonial forces commited in India.

  141. The guy makes a living spewing hate. He went to China, made a living there, married a Chinese person, but he lives off of his hate for China. There are better things for you to do than to be watching this hate.

  142. Apologising = losing face.

    And you know How MUCH the chinese hates it.

    But they didn’t know, being humble encourages goodwill, tighten relationships and bring LONG-TERM prosperity.

    But no, pride precedes all

  143. CCP is still in power because the Chinese people allow it. Any regime is the reflection of collective mindset of the society. Chinese people are also partly to blame, not just the regime. But I still have faith in humanity. Hope they wake up someday.

  144. Breaking News! USA is to be blamed for the Tiananmen Square Massacre. We have found that protestor were influence by western values. China is not at fault, never was.

  145. Umm…when has US said sorry? US has had world dominance and leadership position for decades…. Irony of anti china sentiment is that the underdog is undermore scrutiny than the global richest, most powerful leader nation….fucking morons with low IQ due to failure of for profit capitalism (education, overworking, no time for democracy or lives, bred complacency and trust in corrupt for profit media.) And so we sit here pointing fingers at each other, whilst the oligarchy of global rich run away with our liberties and freedoms. China is just an outlier with everyone else?

  146. Yeah, it’s great timing (the Virus thing) for you to make money as a Youtuber by saying bad things about China. Way better than the money you made in China’s early years.

  147. Look at “America Military News” US navy arrest 300 China Fishing Shops in South America Coast amid food security worries. Also watch “China Observer” China’s Armed Fishermen Miltia is Plundering the Ocean.

  148. It has relationship problems with 25+ countries. USA, Taiwan, Hongkong, Australia, Japan, India, Phillipines, Bhutan, Nepal..the list goes on and on.. is it not proof enough that there’s something faulty in its attitude? It’s bullying its way in all directions. Wish all the countries would gang up together and bring this rogue nation to heel.

  149. You are a murderer if you kill one; you are a devil if you killed ten; But you are a HERO if you killed ten millions, like MaoZeDong. People admire you, respect you, and warship you. That is the ideology in China! and only in China!

  150. well I go to the gym every night and workout for 6 hours, its about relaxing me but I have not been able to do it in almost a year so reason seems like a very big ask

  151. I’ve been noticing recently a lot of pro CCP reply’s to a lot of my comments, I’ve noticed they are doing a lot of pointing fingers instead of defending.

  152. I’m Chinese and I’m 100% agree with you here. China is brain washing people made them believe China was the greatest nation through out the history. And making people believe they have so called the ‘royal blood’ and everything they do is bringing the country back to its glorious days like the Tang Dynasty. Which is completely nonsense, they’ve twisted the history and refuse to accept the reality that they are no where near the modern civilization and ideologies, Chinese CCP is a bunch of crooks and thieves that destroys Chinese people and culture.

  153. Will the west ever condemn its ILLEGAL and Genocidal Zionist wars and constantly funding of Terrorist Rebels in Hitlers Germany, or in modern Vietnam, Afghanistan, Syria, Lebanon, Libya, Sudan, Iraq, Eygpt – all for the profit of Israel??

    Nope, of course they won’t. They will blame everyone except the aggressors and financial slave owners, who cause the wars in the first place. 99% of people don’t even know the arguments of both side and the real timeline of events of things.

    Even Mao was trained up by the Zionists and the West, who originally called themselves Bolsheviks.

    But Western Zionist leaders don’t allow criticism of themselves – just like the Chinese leaders don’t. Let’s stop pretending like China is unique in their oppression.

  154. If ever CCP (to be more precise than just calling out China) to apologise, it will shred its paper-thin face (or lose face) unprecedented since the Middle Kingdom!

  155. The problem in Chinese culture seems to be that the one of “higher (social) authority” is the judge who decides what is right. (What is wrong usually is just what he/she/they don’t like because it puts themselves in a disadvantageous situation.)
    Therefore there is no self-analysis and nearly no sympathy towards those of a lower authority/social standing. (Because they usually cannot fight back, they are punished without any regard for excessive actions, violence or behavior in general.)
    Everyone always acts to the extreme maximum of their own authority/standing. The only limiting factor is another group’s or person’s authority if it is higher than their own.

    The communist party of China is at the very top of the social authority ranking.
    Hence it does not need to apologize from their perspective since there is nobody above them in regards to Chinese authority/social standing.
    So they’ll never apologize unless they lose their social position/authority and are left with no other alternative, but to apologize.

    For everyone researching Chinese behavior: Look at the common themes in Chinese books and even movies. You’ll find that those who apologized never did it because they felt sorry, but because they where left with no other choice to save their own very lives. They had to apologize to avoid dying or being at the very least severely punished without any remorse (because the party doing the punishing was of higher authority and therefore had no limits to guide their actions).

    Of course there are native Chinese people who are appalled by this, but they are the minority.
    If you study enough Chinese literature you’ll see this very clearly. Even modern days movies or series show the very same pattern. The supposed “good guy” or “heroe” in Chinese movies, series or donghua acts completely without compassion or morals whenever he is “on top”. It is very rare for a protagonist in a Chinese story truly act with compassion towards someone he may just as well kill or punish severely. More often then not they’ll punish the other party without holding back at all.

    Please note that although some may interpret it that way, I have no dislike of any “race” or culture.
    I only talk about the differences between them. But as there are exceptions among the people of every country, it is impossible to talk about “all Chinese” or “all Americans” or “all Germans”. It’s just as wrong to judge someone because in the end, nobody acts “bad” on purpose.
    Even the known notoriously “evil political leaders” actually thought they were doing something amazing or “for the greater good”. It is a fact that a person cannot commit to an act that he/she honestly feels is wrong on all levels.

    Acting bad is just an involuntary effect of insufficient understanding/knowledge/experience/balance (of/in oneself).
    For example like with children. But eventually, they will grow up.
    We all do 🙂

  156. C’mon who are you kidding, like anyone in mainland China can see what you’re saying as bad, they would feel offended and take it as an attack because their attitude is wrong to begin with. They all either participate or stand by doing nothing like they usually do, there is no third option for thinking for them. That’s the truth. The majority are like this and in every China town around the world we see their bad behaviour and attitude. It’s crystal clear.

  157. Never once apologized. always trying to save face by lying about the past and glorifying itself. . pretending to be perfect . . well were talking about Donald Trump right?

  158. There is a reason why they call the CCP military the PLA. Liberating from what? All the injustices of history against their people. China last alot in the Opium war.

  159. China has 5,000 years of history but the foreigners caused the fall of Middle Kingdom, an excuse by CCP to resurrect a dead Kingdom!
    Why not resurrect the last Chinese Emperor & sentence him in Mao’s court of 99.9% sure conviction?

  160. The weird thing I’ve seen recently… CGTN or CTGN, whatever they’re called, have hired ex-CNN journalists. This is just a matter of fact too. It’s unsettling. Now that China has a powerful economy, we are starting to see our own institutions working against us. Money has no allegiance :^|

  161. Narcissists Never Say Sorry! Have you divorced your Chinese wife yet? Poor guy. However, I believe you can not make this video without the help from your wife because the content of the video is deep and your knowledge about China is not enough. The only part that could make your wife happy is the video is making her money, I would guess. “Men become bad when they are rich, women become rich when they are bad.” a Chinese saying.

  162. Isn’t it a bit ironic to hear anglo-american preaching after enslaving the whole world “but at least we said sorry”, come on… I think this whole discourse is rotten, because it takes root in nationalism, you have been in a privileged position comparing to most Chinese citizens, you haven’t tasted poverty and exploitation by the west for generations like they have. You are living in your own fantasy bubble, yes you lived in China, but you’ve never really been a Chinese person. You are like the one side of the coin criticizing the other, and one doesn’t exist without the other.

  163. It seems you Yankees are pretty scared of China uh? But who has made them so strong? Who have moved production in China? Spare me this demagoguery

  164. when will china admit it ‘released’ corona (and created a propaganda based fake pandemic) just to save face for losing the trade war? they are literally the worst country on the planet. i detest them.

  165. I agree on most stuff this channel posts, but tbh besides Germany (for obvious reasons), there isn’t really any nation that is apologetic for unpleasant events in its history.

  166. Winston, your experience videos are a lot better imo. These rants come off to me as much more hateful and unnecessary, you call out China for bad behavior, but the truth is, bad behavior is everywhere. Whataboutism is never about excusing your own bad behavior but merely pointing out to you that you have no reason to focus on a specific party’s bad behavior. Grabhagging or whatever is bad, and it doesn’t matter if you’re Chinese or not, it’s just bad. But by focusing on a specific race/culture, it would appear to be prejudicial, even if I know that’s not your intention.

  167. When you are in China, you say something good and something bad. Now you leave and your words become all negative and biased. What you have go through and who put hates into your heart?

  168. I never understood how they could twist it all around and blame other countries for Covid19… And Chinese people would actually believe it…. Its completely next level brainwashing….

  169. Has USA ever apologized for its bad actions. USA has been triggered local wars all over the world in the past couple of decades. When you said what was happening in 1957, why don’t you say something that Chinese has been able to improve their life standards in the past forty years. Also, please educate me how South Africa has discriminated the locals, and how South African apologized for its wrong doings.

  170. Thats why 🇺🇸is the best and 🇰🇷is gettin there too. 🇺🇸 acknowledges their faults and corrects it. They even compensate most times. Best country one can live in. Rule of law is protected and honored no matter how big or small. Thats why the run to this country when wanting a better life. 🇰🇷🤝🇺🇸💪👍

  171. China/N. Korea they are 2 sides of the same horrible coin. A war is inevitable and very much needed. I do not relish the thought a a war but neither can i stomach the crimes against humanity and nature committed by them. sometimes conflict is needed for a better future for those just born. Also Trump is just a guilty for Covid. It did not originate here but his ignorance and lack of action has cause 100’s of thousands of deaths via ignorance. He is a miserable, egotistical human being.

  172. Yes you are right, India had to put up with a thousand years of humiliation but does not feel the need to act like china, is kind to its neighbours etc. It actually is a five thousand year old civilisation too, the only one that can make that claim.

  173. we have been amazing on growing the economic that quick. Tons of people in china became so wealthy dispite the fact most of them were uneducated. But I strongly believe the upcoming generations are changing. And thats changing quickly as well. Just give us some more time.

  174. This is one of the most interesting things that communist and closed societies do in general. They use the advantage of open societies as a disadvantage, pointing out the things that open societies acknowledge as mistakes or great tragedies, and saying: “Look, they even admit it! How can you deny they are evil?!”

  175. Same as aboriginals in Australia.
    They will NEVER admit fault, never say “thank you” and never ever say “sorry”.
    Whats more they will also NEVER repay a debt.

  176. by the way, china just wanted a through investigation throughout the world on where the virus originated. and thats fair to ask for that before taking any blames. china first discovered the virus doesnt neccessarily mean it originated in china

  177. You could have pointed out the root cause of the sparrow extermination in the first place: central command economy. Mao demands ample food, local officials can’t produce enough but pretend otherwise. For a while they can report high numbers, get fat themselves by scalping the food that is available for party uses, but eventually the peasants starve. When this happens someone has to take the blame, and it won’t be anyone in the party, so you have an entire society scapegoating animals.

  178. Chyna CCP is a group of bandits, Chyna created CCP virus and then spread it to the world,
    Accept it CCP virus is just and only Chyna fault, Chyna must pay back,

  179. Making bad excuses is like a immature way to justify your actions and dodging your own mistakes that you made , that is like blaming alcohol and you hit someone because you were drunk/intoxicated.

    It’s about the attitude and you choices in action that lead it to happen in the first place, people just want to wait until bad things happen then they regret it rather than using wisdom to think of what your doing is wrong and predict the outcome.

  180. China China China sounds so familiar hahahahah, bruh so much hate. Relax, you run away to America, be happy and love your wife. Stop making money spreading falls facts and selling bullshits. Only Love

  181. I’ve been following your journey for years and it is refreshing to see you speaking straight from the heart, Winston. It’s as if you are addressing all those Chinese who are willing to listen (despite the obstacles). Your care for the real Chinese compatriots shines through – even if they seem completely disenfranchised in this Marxist leaning system; let’s face it: Their governmental organization has more in common with fascist tenets than communism. Denial seems to have worked for them for three generations but now the price has to be paid – a comp!ete breakdown of their carefully crafted world image.

  182. Every time I was on your side of the war zone, but this time Winston it’s a bit too much even for me. Jesus, come on dude, yea all you said is true. But why use the manipulative music? Why be so one sided?
    Btw I’m not a chinese bot, I love adcchina channels, some of my favorite content on YouTube. Just this vid was too much…

  183. It doesn’t matter, CCP crimes are not something you just forgive, its not even something from the past; its something you stop and punish. IDC if they dont apologise as long as they face justice.

  184. hey, after watching this video to the very end, there is one more thing added to my to-do list. And it’s to Stay Awesome. Great vid by the way, wish i could subscribe more than once

  185. Well neither had Japan or the Western powers apologised for carving up China and subjugation it for a century, destroying the summer Palace, raping and murdering Nanking, and squirreling away billions worth of ancient artifacts in their fantastically curated museums.

  186. In American schools we were taught about things like genocide, slavery, segregation. The lessons went all the way down to the smallest events like some court cases, the LA riots, the anti-Vietnam war protest, the Kent state shootings, the My Lai massacre etc. Many of these small events were pittance compared to the amount of deaths in Tiananmen square massacre ,yet, the Chinese government still doesn’t acknowledge it.

  187. Winston, it must have been a bitter pill for you to swallow when the world was ganging up on South Africa under Apartheid. It must have been tough watch Nelson Mandela get inaugurated, because at the same time Mandela was being inaugurated in May of 1994, Rwanda was experiencing a genocide. A genocide that the rest of the world was hardly paying attention to. Instead, the world was ingratiating Mandela while demonizing the previous Apartheid government. Demonizing Apartheid while ignoring a genocide, yes, it must have been a tough pill to swallow.

    You’re sort of doing the same thing to China, except on steroids. I can’t imagine that the “grab hags” should capture the attention of the world and become a UN issue 🙂 Especially when there is so much human rights abuses all throughout the world.

    But again, you have a family to feed. And with a segment of the US population that has a nationalistic attitude towards China, there is a readily available market for you to sell to. In some ways, I admire your cleverness 🙂

  188. Thank you for making this video. It is all so true !! The problem is : China is not a God fearing country. They don’t believe that one day they will be judged for all the evil they have done !!

  189. It’s understanable, ‘cos one will lead to another, and another, …..
    I guess if you’ve committed so many mistakes, you wouldn’t want to open a Pandora’s box.

  190. The sparrow thing was new to me but now I know why all the birds are gone, I ve seen first hand how they laugh and beat several dogs dead, in Shenzhen Bantian. They say it taste better when it fears for it life, still got pictures and videos as I tried to go against it, but only saved 2 dogs

  191. You know what modern CCP/ communist china party remind me of
    Nazi germany
    Why
    Blame other countries for there problem not them selfs
    Racism problem with minority groups
    Labor camps in the country
    The country is run by one leader only
    What to expend
    Make anyone who against the government disappeared
    Think there country is the best with propaganda poster and pride everywhere
    And that why I think china is
    Similar to nazi Germany
    I don’t know I might ve wrong let me know

  192. The truth is sometimes a hard pill to sparrow, I mean swallow. Seriously though it’s real food for thought and very good insight into what is truth without political correctness. Respect and applause to Winston for telling it.

  193. Why dont you just leave China if you hated this country so much. You will not talk about other race and you are nothing but a white hate mongerer. if you encounter me in China I would make a video of how I will deal with people like you in China and put it in all social media.

  194. Totally agree. Never ever heard china say any kind of sorry.
    The quicker the world rids the ccp pest from world. The better for mankind and the planet.

  195. I know them well, they NEVER apologize unless you got them checkmated and they can get off easy…. otherwise forget it…. arrogance the way of the SCUMBAG !

  196. Western world too scared to take action & punish the CCP for spread & slaughter of the COVID , Hate see when china tries invade western countries western world going be scared then as well ?
    Taiwan > philippines > indonesia thats all the maritime waters taken over off china above australia

  197. Well, hardly any goverment officially apoligized for wrongs of the past… Israel? Turkey? Russia? Did USA officially apologize for the atrocities in Vietnam? Or dropping the bombs on Japan, after the war had already ended? No, everyone lies about the truth and has “explanations” for what happened. Apologizing is still considered to show weakness, same goes for the CCP. I do criticize a lot of what the CCP does and many Chinese willingly fulfill, but the Western world is hardly a shining example for acknowledging own wrongdoings. China has yet to learn that compromises are the way to sustain. No one is perfect, no one is always right and no one is untouchable. This world is bursting with people wielding terrible tools but having empty stomachs or hearts. This could quickly turn into hell for all of us.

  198. If you are Chinese and proudly so, you are not weak for finding this 好难听!If you’re a Westerner he’s totally accurate in all he said. If you’re in the middle 我们可以喝酒。去你妈的病毒。

  199. It should be mentioned that western nations actively commit bad deeds knowing they’ll just need to apologize for it later and maybe pay a token fine to themselves or something to that effect.

    But other than the corruption, there’s also an active attempt to improve, overcome and evolve into a better society that learns from failure.

  200. when does usa apologise last time? when your country south african republic apologise?
    you see the mosquito in enemy eye, but can’t see a log in your own.
    I was better opinion of you

  201. WOW!!!!!!!!!!!! there is a bugs bunny cartoon about this joke. Started with a mouse…get a cat. cat won’t leave…get a dog….dog too aggressive …get a lion…..lion to dangerous…gat an elephant…….elephant too big..get a mouse.

  202. During the cold war, there was a joke. An American tells a Russian that the United States is so free that he can stand in front of the White House and yell, “To hell with Ronald Reagan.” The Russian replies: “This is nothing. I can stand in front of the Kremlin and yell, ‘To hell with Ronald Reagan,’ too.”. Nowadays, in DC, an American can yell, “To hell with the CCP.” The Chinese Gov/CCP replies: “You can’t say that. It’s against our laws!” in Beijing.

  203. Couldn’t have said it any better. Most Chinese people only take the compliments but never the blame. They don’t and never will own up to anything they have done wrong. Always playing the blame game.

  204. China is becoming serious danger to whole world and we all still support their economy – machine behind all of these dangerous behaviour. I hope only they will never send hitmen to silence you.

  205. I have always been curious about Chinese culture but after reading about his purges and fantastically horrific policies and then seeing this video. Thats it I am never going there but Taiwan looks more and more interesting.

  206. The constant denials of actions that are extensively reported make it seem the leaders have NO idea what is happening in their country, they look to be Out of Touch.

  207. I dont think telling people a past event was „good“ is a good thing . I think the same about teaching something is „bad“ (at school) . People and especially kids should build their own opinion so they can think freely

  208. Well … I agree that the virus itself might be chinas fault but it’s 100% the fault of the American government that the US is dealing so bad and unprepared for the virus

  209. Sars started in china . And covid is just the second spread of an evolving virus in less than 20 years.
    Sars 2003. Lets not forget.
    Lack of responsibility

  210. I was watching this, in hopes it would distract me from the USA election. But this just helps support my belief that Trump is right. And Trump knows how to “deal” with the Chinese business class. TRUMP2020

  211. they even taught fake history and changed the history in textbooks and stuff. Also in wiki information like where did the SARs outbreak 2004 came from…
    they changed the facts that the SARs came from their China, GuangDong province to it came from Hong Kong instead in Chinese version. It’s absurd. Their gross tactic to get most of their people may have vpn but cannot read English version so relied on Chinese version to get info. Its disgusting.

Leave a Reply